Compared

Blackbird vs a spreadsheet and a folder of PDFs

Most people billing abroad start with a spreadsheet, a folder of invoice PDFs and a bank statement, and for a while that is genuinely the right answer. This page is about the specific points at which it stops being — and they are specific, not a feeling.

Updated

The short answer

Stay with the spreadsheet while every payment is one client, one invoice, one provider, and you can still name every FIRC. Move when matching has become guesswork, or when a deadline you did not know about has already passed once.

A spreadsheet is still fine if

  • You raise a handful of invoices a year, to one or two clients.
  • Every payment arrives through one route and matches one invoice exactly.
  • You can still say, from memory, which invoices have a FIRC against them.
  • You are not registered for GST and are nowhere near the threshold.

It has outgrown the spreadsheet when

  • Money arrives through two or more providers and each shows you a different fee and a different rate.
  • A payment has arrived short, or one transfer has covered two invoices, and the sheet has no honest way to show it.
  • You are not certain which exports have a certificate and which do not.
  • The nine-month realisation deadline on an invoice has passed, or nearly has, without anyone noticing.
  • A monthly EDF is now due to your bank and the sheet has no idea it exists.
  • You have started guessing at the exchange rate for an invoice rather than looking one up.

Where a sheet actually breaks

Not where people expect. A spreadsheet is excellent at arithmetic and bad at exactly four things, all of which an overseas client brings:

  1. 1Partial and combined payments. One receipt covering two invoices, or an invoice paid 94% because a correspondent bank took a cut, needs a relationship between rows. A sheet has columns.
  2. 2Evidence. A FIRC is a file. A sheet can hold its number; it cannot tell you which three exports have no file at all, which is the question that matters.
  3. 3Deadlines that are per row. Nine months from each invoice, not a date in the year. Nobody maintains thirty of those by hand.
  4. 4Being checked. When a figure is queried, you need to show where it came from. A cell containing 170000 remembers nothing about the rate, the date or the invoice.

What you give up by moving

A spreadsheet is yours, offline, free and infinitely flexible. Moving to any tool costs you flexibility and adds a dependency, and anyone who tells you otherwise is selling something.

The honest mitigations: the free plan covers three GST invoices a month with no card, so the move is reversible before it costs anything, and everything you put in comes back out as records, originals and manifests — see data exports and service continuity. Keep your own copies regardless; that page says so too.

Blackbird is the paperwork of being paid from abroad: an export invoice under your LUT, the payment matched to it, the FIRC or FIRA that proves it arrived in foreign exchange, the monthly Export Declaration Form your bank expects, the GST position that falls out, and an estimate of the tax to set aside. It is not a general ledger and it is not a filing agent.

Blackbird files nothing. GSTR-1 comes out as a JSON you upload yourself, GSTR-3B as a sheet to check line by line, the EDF as a draft for your bank. Every figure it prepares is explained on the tax calculation methodology page, including the things it refuses to decide.

The middle path, which is underrated

Keep the spreadsheet for whatever it is good at — your own projections, your pipeline, the rates you charge — and let a tool hold the records that have an external deadline attached. The things that bite are the dated ones, and those are the ones a sheet is worst at.

What to ask a spreadsheet

We will not tell you from the outside what another product, or another person, can and cannot do. These are the questions that settle it, and they take a minute to ask.

  • Ask yourself: can you name, right now, every export invoice with no certificate against it?
  • When is the earliest realisation deadline you are currently carrying?
  • What did your last transfer actually cost, against the reference rate for that day?
  • If a figure on last year’s return were queried, could you show where it came from?

Questions people ask

Is a spreadsheet non-compliant?
No. Nothing requires software. The rules care about the records and the deadlines, not the tool. A sheet maintained properly is compliant; the risk is that maintaining it properly stops happening.
Can I import what I already have?
Business-scoped CSV imports are supported, reviewed row by row before anything is recorded.
What if I want to leave?
Database records, originals and review manifests all download. Data exports and service continuity says exactly what each export contains and what it does not.
Is the free plan actually usable?
Three GST invoices a month, no card. It is enough to run a real month through before deciding anything.

Sources

Read next

This page explains the rules in general. It is not tax or legal advice for your business; check anything you act on with your CA.